UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres is raising the alarm over "a frightening report" on climate that shows 2020 was one of the three hottest years on record, marked by wildfires, droughts, floods, melting glaciers and rising sea levels. (April 19) AP Domestic
The claim: Images of a lighthouse in 1900 and 2021 prove sea levels haven't risen
Social media users shared photos of a lighthouse in Hawaii to falsely claim sea-level rise is a hoax.
A Facebook post on June 15 shows two images of a cliff-side lighthouse that were purportedly taken a century apart. One image is labeled “1900” and the other “2021.”
“SAME Lighthouse 120 years apart. The Ocean Levels haven’t changed ONE bit,” says text in the image.
There's one problem with that: The lighthouse in the images didn't exist in 1900. The Facebook post also disregards the effect of tides on sea levels, as well as the science of climate change.
Fact check: Scientific consensus says humans are dominant cause of climate change
USA TODAY was unable to reach the user who shared the post for comment.
Lighthouse wasn't built until 1912
Using reverse image search, USA TODAY identified the lighthouse as the Daniel K. Inouye Kilauea Point Lighthouse in Kauai, Hawaii. It didn't exist in 1900, as the Facebook post claims.
In an email to USA TODAY, Thomas Daubert, executive director of Friends of Kauai Wildlife Refuges, confirmed the images show Kilauea Point.
USA TODAY could not verify when each image was taken, but the lighthouse's construction didn't begin until 1912.
"Construction was completed on May 1, 1913. It is indeed not 120 years old," Daubert said.
Fact check: False claim persists that planes weren't used in 9/11 attacks on World Trade Center
He suggested the image purportedly taken in 1900 was probably taken several decades later.
"The (black-and-white) image shows a small piece of a building to the left of the lighthouse, which wasn't built until 1929 with the advent of radar," Daubert said.
Tides affect sea level hour-to-hour, day-to-day
Regardless of when the images were taken, the Facebook post disregards the effect of tides.
Sea levels would have appeared lower or higher at the lighthouse depending on the time, day and season each photo was taken. National Geographic explained that sea level can vary by several meters in inlets and bays, depending on tides.
Fact check: False claim ties Biden's climate plan to reducing meat consumption
Keryn Gedan is an assistant professor of biology at George Washington University who researches the effect of climate change on marine ecosystems and sea level. She told USA TODAY visual comparison is "a poor way" to measure sea-level change.
"It can be difficult to discern the tidal stage from a photograph. Depending on the location, tides can be up to 50 vertical feet," she said.
Other photos of the Kilauea Point Lighthouse from similar angles show tides at varied heights.
Data shows sea levels are rising
Though long-term changes in sea level cannot be measured with the naked eye, government data shows sea levels are changing.
According to the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, sea levels have risen 6 to 8 inches around the globe in the past century. That rate of change is unprecedented over the past several thousand years, NASA said.
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration data shows sea levels in Nawiliwili Harbor in Kauai are rising at an average rate of 0.58 feet every 100 years.
Experts attribute rising sea levels to climate change.
"Our best science, in the form of ever-refined global Earth models, suggests that this acceleration will continue over the next century and result in much higher rates of sea-level rise than we have yet experienced today," Gedan said. "It is important for coastal areas to prepare and plan for this eventuality."
Fact check: Frozen wind turbines don't deserve all the blame for Texas blackouts
In April, USA TODAY debunked a similar claim which falsely argued side-by-side images of Palm Beach in Australia proved sea levels hadn't risen.
Our rating: False
The claim that images of a lighthouse in 1900 and 2021 prove sea levels haven't risen is FALSE, based on our research. The timeline at the center of the comparison is inaccurate, as the Kilauea Lighthouse was not built until 1912. Official data confirms sea levels across the globe and near Kauai are rising because of climate change. Visual comparisons of shorelines do not reflect the effects of climate change; sea-level changes are often within a few inches and vary with the tide.
Our fact check sources:
- Yandex, accessed June 16
- U.S. Fish & Wildlife Services, accessed June 16, Daniel K. Inouye Kīlauea Point Lighthouse Tours
- Thomas Daubert, June 17, Email correspondence with USA TODAY
- Friends of Kauai Wildlife refuges, accessed June 16, History Of The Kīlauea Lighthouse
- National Geographic, accessed June 16, Cause and Effect: Tides
- Keryn Gedan, June 18, Email correspondence with USA TODAY
- Tripadvisor, accessed June 16, Kauai Photo: Kaui's Lighthouse
- Shutter Stock, accessed June 16, White Lighthouse set atop a cliff with a brilliant blue ocean in the background in Kauai, Hawaii, USA.
- NASA, Sea Level Change, accessed June 16, How long have sea levels been rising? How does recent sea level rise compare to that over the previous centuries?
- NOAA, Tides & Currents, accessed June 16, Sea Level Trends
- USA TODAY, April 23, Fact check: Photos show no change in sea level over 99 years but don't disprove climate change
Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.
Our fact check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook
Read or Share this story: https://ift.tt/3vDVkCF
The Link LonkJune 21, 2021 at 04:20AM
https://ift.tt/3vDVkCF
Fact check: Photos of Hawaii lighthouse don't disprove sea-level rise - USA TODAY
https://ift.tt/2CoSmg4
Sea
/cloudfront-us-east-2.images.arcpublishing.com/reuters/CZF6NULMVVMEXHOP7JK5BSPQUM.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment